Penis pumps occupy an unusual corner of men's sexual health.
On one hand, they're heavily marketed online with promises of larger erections, permanent growth and improved sexual performance.
On the other, vacuum erection devices are legitimate medical devices that have been used to treat erectile dysfunction for decades.
So what actually works - and what's marketing?
A penis pump can reliably help many men create an erection for sexual activity. It may also have a role in penile rehabilitation, particularly after prostate surgery. What it doesn't do is permanently enlarge a healthy penis or cure every underlying cause of erectile dysfunction.
Here's what men should know.
A penis pump used medically is more accurately called a vacuum erection device, or VED.
The device consists of a cylinder placed over the penis and a pump that removes air from the cylinder. The resulting negative pressure draws blood into the erectile tissue, causing the penis to become engorged and erect.
If the goal is intercourse, a constriction ring can then be placed around the base of the penis to help retain blood after the cylinder is removed.
The mechanism is relatively simple - and it doesn't require the same erectile signaling needed for medications such as Viagra or Cialis.
That makes vacuum erection devices useful for men with several different types of ED.
Yes.
Vacuum erection devices are an established treatment for erectile dysfunction and are included in major urology guidelines.
Studies generally find that many men can produce an erection adequate for intercourse with a properly used VED. A recent systematic review and meta-analysis involving more than 1,000 men with difficult-to-treat ED found an overall efficacy rate of approximately 80%, although outcomes varied among different patient groups.
That doesn't mean 80% of men love using one.
Effectiveness and satisfaction aren't necessarily the same thing.
A pump can produce an erection quite reliably, but some men find the process cumbersome or dislike the way the resulting erection feels. Others appreciate having a drug-free treatment that works predictably.
There is a lot of misinformation surrounding penis pumps. These are some of the most common claims.
Fact.
This is what vacuum erection devices are designed to do.
Negative pressure draws blood into the penis. A constriction ring placed at the base can then reduce venous outflow and help maintain the erection during sexual activity.
This can work even when normal erectile physiology is impaired, which is why VEDs can be useful in men with diabetes, vascular disease, neurologic conditions or ED following prostate surgery.
Fiction.
A vacuum device temporarily increases penile length and girth by filling the erectile tissue with blood.
That's an erection - not permanent penile enlargement.
There is not good evidence that routine use of a vacuum erection device permanently increases the size of a normal penis.
This distinction matters because many consumer penis pumps are marketed primarily around enlargement rather than erectile dysfunction.
If permanent enlargement is the promise, skepticism is warranted.
Fact - with some nuance.
Vacuum devices are frequently incorporated into penile rehabilitation programs after radical prostatectomy.
After prostate surgery, temporary nerve dysfunction can reduce spontaneous and nighttime erections. That decrease in erectile activity may contribute to changes in penile tissue and loss of penile length.
Studies suggest that early vacuum therapy may help preserve penile length and improve erectile-function measures during rehabilitation.
What remains less certain is whether vacuum therapy actually accelerates or increases the eventual recovery of spontaneous, unassisted erections.
So the goal of post-prostatectomy vacuum therapy may be different from simply using a pump immediately before sex.
Not exactly.
We would be cautious with this claim.
Vacuum therapy increases blood volume within the penis while the device is being used, and there is biologic rationale for its use in certain rehabilitation settings.
But describing routine pumping as the equivalent of taking the penis to the gym - and suggesting that healthy men can prevent age-related ED simply by pumping regularly - goes beyond the available evidence.
For men concerned about preventing ED, cardiovascular and metabolic health have substantially stronger evidence behind them.
Blood pressure, cholesterol, glucose control, exercise, smoking, weight and overall vascular health all matter to erectile function.
Possibly, but this is a different use.
Vacuum devices are sometimes incorporated into treatment strategies for men with Peyronie's disease or penile shortening.
The goal isn't to “pump away” the plaque.
Mechanical therapies may be used to help preserve or improve penile length and function in selected patients, but treatment should be individualized based on the degree of curvature, plaque, erectile function and whether the disease is stable.
A vacuum device also isn't interchangeable with penile traction therapy, which uses a different mechanical approach.
Peyronie's Disease Treatment →
When a vacuum erection device is being used for intercourse, the general process is straightforward.
The cylinder is placed over the penis to create a seal against the body. Air is gradually removed, creating negative pressure and drawing blood into the penis.
Once an adequate erection develops, a constriction ring is transferred from the cylinder to the base of the penis. The cylinder is then removed.
The ring helps maintain the erection during sexual activity.
It should not be left in place indefinitely. Current European Association of Urology patient guidance advises removing the constriction ring within 30 minutes.
Men using a vacuum device as part of a rehabilitation program may use it differently, often without a constriction ring. That protocol should be determined by the treating clinician.
A vacuum-assisted erection can feel somewhat different from a spontaneous erection.
Some men notice:
The erection may also look slightly different because the mechanism of blood flow is different from a physiologic erection.
None of this necessarily means the device isn't working.
The more relevant question is whether the erection is comfortable and adequate for sexual activity.
Vacuum erection devices are generally safe when used properly, but excessive vacuum pressure or improper use can cause injury.
Potential side effects include:
The AUA recommends using a device with a vacuum limiter, which prevents excessive negative pressure and reduces the risk of penile injury.
Men with bleeding disorders or who take anticoagulant medications should discuss vacuum-device use with their clinician because bruising and bleeding may be more likely.
The constriction ring should generally be removed within 30 minutes.
Leaving it on too long can impair circulation and increase the risk of pain, numbness, bruising or tissue injury.
More time does not create a better result.
If the erection is inadequate despite correct use, the answer is not to simply leave the ring on longer. Technique, device fit or another ED treatment may need to be reconsidered.
There is an enormous range of devices online, from legitimate vacuum erection systems to inexpensive products marketed primarily for sexual enhancement.
For ED treatment, look for a vacuum erection device designed specifically for that purpose.
Important features include:
Manual and battery-powered pumps can both work.
The key isn't whether a device produces the strongest possible suction. Excessive vacuum is neither necessary nor desirable. Controlled negative pressure is the goal.
Neither is inherently better.
They solve the problem differently.
Viagra, Cialis and other PDE5 inhibitors enhance the body's natural erectile response to sexual stimulation.
A vacuum erection device mechanically draws blood into the penis.
Oral medication tends to feel more spontaneous, which is one reason many men prefer it when it works well.
A vacuum device has other advantages: it doesn't require systemic medication, can work when oral medications don't, and can be used by many men whose erectile physiology has been significantly impaired.
The two approaches can also sometimes be used together under appropriate medical guidance.
Trimix and vacuum devices can both be effective when oral ED medications aren't producing adequate erections.
Trimix uses medication injected directly into the erectile tissue to create an erection. A vacuum device uses negative pressure mechanically.
For some men, Trimix produces a more natural-feeling and predictable erection. Others prefer avoiding injections and are comfortable using a pump.
The right choice depends largely on the severity of ED, medical history and patient preference.
Trimix Injections for Erectile Dysfunction: How They Work, Effectiveness and Side Effects →
These treatments have very different goals.
A vacuum erection device can mechanically produce an erection immediately. Its effectiveness for that purpose is well established.
Low-intensity shockwave therapy does not create an immediate erection. It is being studied for its potential to improve erectile function over time, particularly in men with vasculogenic ED.
The evidence supporting shockwave therapy continues to evolve, and results vary based on patient selection, device and protocol.
For some men, the two treatments aren't mutually exclusive.
A vacuum device can provide reliable assistance with erections while other aspects of erectile health are evaluated or treated.
Shockwave Therapy for ED Success Rate: What Does the Evidence Actually Show? →
No.
A vacuum erection device can be extremely effective at producing an erection, but it doesn't necessarily correct whatever caused the ED.
That cause may be vascular, metabolic, neurologic, hormonal, medication-related, psychological - or a combination.
This is why we don't think men should interpret needing a pump, Viagra, Cialis or Trimix as the end of the evaluation.
Particularly when ED is new or progressing, it is worth understanding why.
At Performance Men's Health, we consider vacuum erection devices a legitimate and useful ED treatment.
They're inexpensive compared with many procedural treatments, drug-free and effective for many men.
We also use them selectively as part of penile rehabilitation strategies when appropriate.
But a pump is a tool - not a diagnosis.
If erectile function has changed, we also want to understand the factors contributing to that change, including vascular and cardiovascular health, metabolic health, medications, testosterone when appropriate, previous pelvic or prostate surgery and other potential causes.
The goal is not simply to create an erection.
It's to find the most effective, practical treatment while understanding what the ED may be telling us about the patient's broader health.
Yes. Vacuum erection devices are an established medical treatment for ED and can produce erections adequate for intercourse in many men, including men who don't respond adequately to oral ED medications.
There is not good evidence that vacuum pumps permanently increase the size of a normal penis. They temporarily increase length and girth as blood is drawn into the erectile tissue.
A vacuum erection device generally produces an erection within several minutes. European urology patient guidance notes that it can take up to approximately 10 minutes.
A constriction ring should generally be removed within 30 minutes. Leaving it on longer increases the risk of numbness, bruising, pain and tissue injury.
Vacuum devices are sometimes used regularly or even daily in specific penile rehabilitation protocols, particularly after prostate surgery. Frequency should depend on the purpose of treatment and individual medical circumstances.
Yes. A constriction ring is typically used when the goal is to maintain an erection for intercourse. Vacuum therapy used for rehabilitation may be performed without a ring.
In selected patients, vacuum erection devices can be combined with PDE5 inhibitors such as Viagra or Cialis. Combination treatment should be discussed with a clinician, particularly when ED is significant or other medications and medical conditions are involved.
Generally, yes, when an appropriate device is used correctly. A device with a vacuum limiter is preferable, and excessive suction should be avoided. Men with bleeding disorders or taking anticoagulants should discuss use with their clinician.
Schedule a consultation with the Performance Men's Health team.