Not all shockwave therapy for erectile dysfunction is the same.
The term “shockwave” is now used to describe a wide range of treatments and devices - from medical-grade focused shockwave systems to radial pressure-wave devices and consumer products marketed for home use.
They don't all deliver the same type of energy, and research performed with one technology can't automatically be applied to another.
At Performance Men's Health, we've been deliberate about the technology we use. The PMH team uses medical-grade shockwave systems manufactured by Storz Medical, a long-established medical shockwave company whose devices have been extensively used and studied in other areas of medicine.
We have both focused shockwave and radial pressure-wave technology available. Focused shockwaves can concentrate energy at a defined depth within tissue, while radial pressure waves disperse more broadly and are strongest closer to the surface.
Having both technologies matters because they are not interchangeable - and because we don't believe every patient or treatment objective should automatically be approached with the same device.
That distinction is particularly important in erectile dysfunction, where the research itself has used different technologies, energy settings and treatment protocols.
So if you're considering shockwave therapy for ED, it is worth asking more than:
“Does shockwave work?”
You should also ask:
“What kind of shockwave are you using?”
The easiest way to understand the difference is to think about how the energy is delivered.
Focused shockwave systems generate acoustic waves that converge at a defined point within the tissue.
This allows the energy to be directed to a specific depth rather than being concentrated primarily near the surface.
Focused shockwave is also the technology represented in much of the published research on low-intensity shockwave therapy for erectile dysfunction.
Radial pressure-wave devices work differently.
The energy is strongest near the applicator and spreads outward as it travels through the tissue. This creates a broader, more superficial treatment field.
Radial technology is well established in musculoskeletal medicine and has also been studied for ED, although the erectile-dysfunction evidence is considerably smaller than the evidence base for focused shockwave.
This doesn't mean radial technology has no role.
It means focused and radial treatments should not simply be lumped together as though they are the same intervention.
Because medical research evaluates specific treatments - not the word “shockwave.”
A clinical trial uses a particular device with a particular waveform, energy level, number of pulses and treatment protocol.
If another machine delivers energy in a substantially different way, we can't simply assume it will produce the same results.
This is one of the challenges in interpreting shockwave research for ED.
Studies have differed in:
There is still no universally accepted “best” shockwave protocol for erectile dysfunction.
That doesn't mean the technology doesn't work.
It means the details matter.
The best evidence for shockwave therapy is in men with mild-to-moderate vasculogenic ED - erectile dysfunction in which impaired vascular function and blood flow are important contributors.
Recent systematic reviews suggest low-intensity shockwave therapy can modestly improve erectile function in some men, but the results aren't uniform.
One reason is the enormous variation in devices, protocols and patients across studies.
Professional organizations also interpret the evidence differently. European urology guidelines allow for its use in selected men with vasculogenic ED, while U.S. organizations remain more cautious and continue to consider the treatment investigational or insufficiently proven for routine use.
We think that uncertainty is important to acknowledge.
In our clinical experience, appropriately selected men can see meaningful improvement with shockwave therapy. But not everyone responds, and we don't present shockwave as a cure for every type of ED.
Patient selection matters just as much as the machine.
Shockwave Therapy for ED Success Rate: What Does the Evidence Actually Show? →
Based on the current evidence, focused shockwave has the stronger research base for erectile dysfunction.
Most of the clinical trials underlying current ED recommendations have used focused shockwave technology.
A recent systematic review comparing focused and radial therapy found improvement with both, with greater overall improvement in the focused-treatment studies. However, the studies varied enough that we would not interpret this as proof that focused technology is always better in every patient.
This is also why we don't think the answer is simply choosing the machine with the most power.
Focused and radial systems deliver energy differently. Energy level, treatment depth, location, protocol and the patient's underlying physiology all matter.
One misconception in shockwave marketing is that a more powerful machine must produce a better result.
That hasn't been established.
The goal is not to deliver the maximum amount of energy possible.
It is to deliver the appropriate type and amount of energy to the appropriate tissue using a thoughtful protocol.
This is another reason we use medical-grade technology and have more than one treatment modality available rather than relying on a single machine for every patient.
The terminology surrounding shockwave treatment can be confusing.
GAINSWave, for example, is a brand and provider network - not a specific shockwave device.
Likewise, terms such as “acoustic wave,” “sound wave” and “shockwave” are sometimes used loosely in advertising.
The treatment name alone doesn't tell you what technology is actually being used.
If you're considering treatment, ask what device the clinic uses and whether it generates focused shockwaves, radial pressure waves or another form of acoustic energy.
The same principle applies to home devices.
Consumer products are increasingly marketed as at-home versions of clinical shockwave therapy.
That doesn't necessarily mean they deliver the same treatment.
Most of the research supporting low-intensity shockwave therapy for ED has been performed using medical-grade systems under controlled clinical protocols.
If a consumer device generates a different waveform, energy output or treatment depth, the results from those studies cannot automatically be applied to it.
The relevant question is:
Has this particular device, delivering this particular type of energy using this protocol, actually been shown to improve erectile function?
For many at-home devices, high-quality device-specific evidence is lacking.
The Phoenix ED Device Review: Does At-Home Shockwave Therapy Actually Work? →
No shockwave device is currently FDA approved specifically for the treatment of erectile dysfunction.
Some medical shockwave systems, including technologies used in our practice, have FDA clearance for other medical indications such as certain musculoskeletal conditions.
Their use for erectile dysfunction is off-label.
That distinction is important.
FDA clearance for a medical device in one application should not be presented as FDA approval of shockwave therapy for ED.
When the PMH team decided to offer shockwave therapy, we wanted established medical technology rather than a device developed primarily around the consumer ED market.
We chose Storz Medical, a company with decades of experience developing medical shockwave systems used across multiple areas of medicine.
We also chose to have both focused and radial technology available rather than limiting treatment to one type of device.
But technology alone isn't what determines whether someone is a good candidate.
Before recommending shockwave therapy, we consider:
We have seen meaningful improvement in appropriately selected patients.
We have also seen patients who don't respond.
That's why our approach isn't “everyone with ED needs shockwave.”
It's to determine why a man's erectile function has changed, whether shockwave makes sense for his particular physiology, and which treatment approach gives him the best chance of improvement.
If you're considering shockwave therapy for ED, ask:
The provider should be able to answer those questions.
Shockwave therapy for ED is not one standardized treatment.
Focused and radial technologies are different. Devices are different. Protocols are different. And the men receiving treatment are different.
That makes it inappropriate to assume that research performed with one medical shockwave system validates every treatment marketed as “shockwave therapy.”
At Performance Men's Health, we've intentionally invested in medical-grade focused and radial shockwave technology because we want the ability to select treatment thoughtfully rather than force every patient into the same protocol.
The technology matters.
But choosing the right patient - and understanding the cause of his ED - matters even more.
Focused shockwave concentrates acoustic energy at a defined depth within tissue. Radial pressure-wave energy is strongest near the applicator and spreads more broadly as it travels through tissue. They are different technologies and should not automatically be considered interchangeable.
Focused shockwave currently has the larger evidence base for erectile dysfunction, and most of the clinical trials supporting shockwave treatment for ED have used focused technology. That does not mean focused treatment is necessarily superior for every patient or application.
Yes. Devices can differ in waveform, energy delivery and treatment depth. Results from research performed with one type of technology cannot automatically be assumed to apply to a substantially different device.
No. GAINSWave is a brand and provider network rather than a specific medical device. Providers using the GAINSWave name may use different equipment.
Not necessarily. There is no established evidence that simply delivering more energy produces better erectile outcomes. Technology, protocol, treatment location and patient selection all matter.
No. Shockwave therapy is not FDA approved specifically for erectile dysfunction. Some medical shockwave systems are FDA cleared for other indications and used off-label for ED.
That has not been established. Most ED research has used medical-grade shockwave systems. Results from those studies should not automatically be extrapolated to consumer devices that may deliver substantially different energy and waveforms.
Schedule a consultation with the Performance Men's Health team.